Pelagianism, Free Will, & the Theological Argument That Never Ended
The Council of Carthage declared Pelagius a heretic in 418 CE. The argument he was condemned for has not stopped since. It resurfaces in every theological tradition that takes seriously the question of human moral responsibility — including Islam, which arrived centuries later and proceeded to have the same argument with considerable vigour. The Man and the Controversy Pelagius was a British monk — his origins are debated, but the sources consistently place him as coming from the British Isles — who arrived in Rome around 380 CE and built a significant reputation as an ascetic and moral teacher. His public life was austere. His rhetoric was persuasive. Bishop Aurelius Augustinus Hipponensis called him a saintly man before calling him a heretic. The transition between those two assessments tells you something about the intensity of the theological stakes involved. Bishop Augustine of Hippo summarised it in The Spirit and the Letter IV : “There is an opinion ...