Is Comparative Religion Necessary for Da'wah?

بِسۡمِ ٱللهِ ٱلرَّحۡمَـٰنِ ٱلرَّحِيمِ

For the longest time, there was this prevalent belief in certain Muslim organisations that to engage in da’wah, it is necessary to have knowledge in comparative religion.  It is a veil and irrelevant to the issue of faith.  Some people believe that to bring someone to Islam, it was necessary to point out in an intellectual discussion what is wrong with their religious beliefs and why Islam is the answer.

Firstly, as much as we would like to believe so, any discussion involving a belief system is anything but emotionless.  We are talking about the ideas, and passions that rule our lives intrinsically.  Look at the Muslims for example; because of cartoons that insulted the Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.), they were ready to burn down whole neighbourhoods, torch an embassy and send death threats.  Ironically, to defend Rasullulah (s.a.w.), they violated the tenets of the faith and transgressed the sunnah.

Secondly, many Muslims who try to use this tactic only highlight their ignorance.  They do no know enough of their own religion to talk about others’ faith.  Bible study seems to be the rage, even amongst asatidzah.  In fact, some of them seem to have made a name for themselves as ‘experts’ in Christianity.  Unfortunately, just as any person who does critical analysis of the Qur’an by not referring to the Arabic text is dismissed, quoting a few lines in English does not constitute Bible study.  Much of the Old Testament was written in Hebrew and Aramaic.  Much of the New Testament was in Koine Greek.  Just as you cannot understand the Qur’an in parts without reference to the hadits, exegesis and historical knowledge; there is a whole body of liturgical works that are ignored by believing that the Bible is central to every Christian belief.

So what is the key to da’wah?  Muslims believe that it is fithrah, our natural disposition to believe in Allah (s.w.t.).  But they do not fully understand what that is.  Fithrah is not merely the intrinsic belief that there is something out there, it is the recognition within our souls the very Nature of Allah (s.w.t.).  It is the memory of the time when Allah (s.w.t.) brought forth the souls of Bani Adam to affirm that he is ar-Rabb.  We remember the Day of Promises at a deep spiritual level.  The Truth is intrinsic.  But since the hearts are not pure, the light is distorted or dimmed.  That memory slumbers in the deepest recesses of our subconscious.  We will know our Maker and His Signs when that memory stirs to consciousness.  It is the state of ma’rifat, gnosis.  To some, it is more developed than others.  Perhaps only a shaykh may show you how to open the door.  But a da’i may show you that the door is there.

People become Muslims because of the quest of spirituality.  Each and every one of us is a seeker, a traveler trying to find the way Home.  We are in the desert trying to find the Garden.  So we follow the ways of the Sufis.  They will show us what da’wah is.  Da’wah is humility, kindness, surety and a belief that we are instruments of the Will.  Comparative religion as a method of da’wah is like the man who makes endless comments about your mode of transportation instead of pointing the way.


  1. I feel comparative religion is good but I don't think it should be used as a primary vehicle for da'wah. Tearing down the other's party defense wall will leave them exposed and very defensive. I always approach in getting them on to our wall and eventually the rest will fall into place. Allah knows best.. but this is an interesting post.

  2. Thank you. It was a point Mudpie & I were discussing. If you notice, Darul Arqam is somehow going back in that direction again.

  3. I notice at least with the befrienders because I am not involved with other divisions. But yes, I do feel that there are some in the befrienders group (perhaps unintentionally) like to take on the path of comparative when discussing. Hopefully further education can tune the approach to something more appropriate.

  4. The axiom used to be "Allah and Prophet are sufficient for me", to some extent, the need for regulation and safeguards around the process of conversion attempts to protect the convert. The subsequent complexities arise from a further need to be proficient in that protection. I propose fostering a homely environment; where muslims and non-muslims alike can feel at peace.

    Whichever way we head, the concept of comparative studies should be applied in reaching out to someone who is on the verge of embracing Islam; not demolishing pre-existing beliefs or making comparisons on matters of faith.

    The discussions on the divinity of Jesus (peace be upon him) and the nature of the trinity can all come later.

    To use an example that Harlequin had used earlier today during coffee with HipHop and I (albeit with slight modifications):

    If someone were standing at the edge of a cliff, would you push him over the edge or pull him toward you?

    Or would you prefer to debate with him the merits of standing on the edge / falling over the edge?

  5. as'salamualaikum terence, i'm your friend (during NS time) and i would like to stay in touch with you again. just don't know how??

    1. Wa 'Alaykum as-Salaam,

      My FB: Terence Nunis.

      Wa as-Salaam


Post a Comment

Thank you for taking the time to share our thoughts. Once approved, your comments will be posted.

Popular posts from this blog

In Saudi Arabia, Mawlid is Bid'ah, the King's Birthday is Fine

Singapore Bans Ismail Menk from Entry

Some Depictions of the Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.) in Art